student success

The Power of Institutional Choice

Julie BryantVice President for Student SuccessMarch 5, 2019

Have you ever considered the power of the perception of institutional choice? If students want to be at your institution—if you are their first choice — they are more likely to have higher satisfaction with their overall experience. If they indicate that you were their second or third choice, their satisfaction scores are lower overall.

This insight was first shared ina blog I wroteon the 2018 National Student Satisfaction and Priorities Report when it was released last fall. The 2018 Report looks more closely at the differences in student satisfaction by a variety of demographic subpopulation indicators, including self-reported institutional choice.

As previously noted, the good news about institutional choice is the perception of institutional choice is something we can potentially influence as we are working to recruit and retain students on our campuses. This in turn will help to improve overall student satisfaction. This is important because we know from theresearchthat student satisfaction is linked to higher individual student retention, higher institutional graduation rates and higher institutional alumni giving rates.

How likely are students to be attending their first institutional choice?

The majority of students at four-year privates, four-year publics, and community colleges indicate that their institution was their first choice:

Percentage of students enrolled at their first-, second-, and third-choice institutions. Data from the2018 National Student Satisfaction and Priorities Report

Do you know how many of your students believe your institution to be their first choice? (If you have recent results from an administration of theStudent Satisfaction Inventory™, check the demographic report section for the answer to this question).

Where are second- and third-choice students less satisfied?

If a student perceives themselves to be at a second- or third-choice institution, they are more likely to have lower satisfaction with items related to campus climate, or how they feel on campus. For example, at four-year private and public institutions nationally, second- and third-choice students were significantly less satisfied with these items:

  • It is an enjoyable experience to be a student on this campus.
  • Students are made to feel welcome on this campus.
  • I am able to experience intellectual growth here.
  • Tuition paid is a worthwhile investment.

These students are also more likely to reflect lower satisfaction with the admissions counselors accurately portraying the campus during the recruitment experience.

Second- and third-choice students at community colleges had lower satisfaction on similar items.

What can you do to influence institutional choice?

Here are three suggestions to influence institutional choice at your institution:

1. Be aware of your students’ perceptions of institutional choice.

Track this information from yourStudent Satisfaction Inventoryresults, or have some other method to capture it through the admissions process. Be aware of how this indication compares with your peer institutions and how if shifts over time.

2. Use communication to influence and change perceptions.

I had a client say to me, “Institutional choice is a branding issue. We have to work harder at getting students to buy into the college.” This starts with how you position the college through the recruitment process and continues once the students get on campus. Act like a first-choice institution, and highlight the reasons why currently enrolled students feel you are the best fit for them. Emphasize the unique experiences that students can only have, or best have, at your college.

3. Control what you can.

Look for ways that you can attract the students who are excited to attend your college, by offering the right amount of financial aid and the right programs. Maintain your campus appearance. Put a strong emphasis on your campus climate by intentionally welcoming students and helping them to find where they belong.

Download the 2018 National Student Satisfaction and Priorities Report

I encourage you to download the current National Student Satisfaction and Priorities Reportand take a closer look at the satisfaction findings across a variety of demographic variables, including race/ethnicity, class level, gender, age, employment, current residence, class load and educational goal.

ACE Conference SessionI will be presenting on this topic, “First Choice Institution or No? Why it Matters for Enrollment and Retention Success,” on Monday, March 11, at the American Council on Education (ACE) Conference in Philadelphia. If you will be attending the conference, I invite you to join the discussion during the session. Or if you would like to visit further about student satisfaction assessment on your campus,contact me directly anytime.

About the Author

Julie Bryant of RNL

Julie L. Bryant, vice president for student success at RNL, works directly with colleges and universities throughout North America in the area of satisfaction assessment. Julie is responsible for client service to more than 2,700 institutions...

Read more about Julie's experience and expertise

Reach Julie by e-mail at

Read More In: Student Success
Read More Blogs By: Julie Bryant